If I’m reading this right, the White House appears to be confirming that it believes the new law explicitly allows eavesdropping not just on foreigners talking to foreigners, but also on Americans talking to foreigners. All they have to do is claim that the real target is the foreigner and that a “significant purpose” of the eavesdropping is related to intelligence gathering. Not terrorism, mind you, just intelligence generically. What’s more, they don’t even have to go to the minimal trouble of making that claim to a court. They can just make it and approve it themselves.
So that’s that. The government is now legally allowed to monitor all your calls overseas with only the most minimal oversight.
I don’t even know what to say.
UPDATE: There’s more here (linkage also via Kevin). For example:
The Democratic bill…and this is critical…explicitly excluded (1) communications with a U.S. person inside the United States and (2) communications in which all participants are in the United States. Thus, the bill provided protections against domestic surveillance. For these types of calls, the government needed an old-fashioned warrant. (The Democratic bill’s carve-out provisions are in Sec. 105B(c)(1)(A).)
The White House bill (pdf) — soon to be law — took a much different approach. It just flatly withdrew all of this surveillance from the FISA regime. More specifically, the bill (Sec. 105A) states that any “surveillance directed at a person reasonably believed” to be outside the United States is completely exempt from FISA (i.e., it’s not considered “electronic surveillance”). [Marty] Lederman spells all this out very well and in more detail, but the upshot is virtually anything — including calls inside the United States or involving U.S. citizens — is fair game.
Prepare for company when making international calls
From Kevin Drum:
I don’t even know what to say.
UPDATE: There’s more here (linkage also via Kevin). For example:
Related Articles
Surrendering the Bill of Rights in the 21st Century
Three stories I read today shared a common thread: the slow, but ubiquitous degradation of some fundamental freedoms in name of the modern police state....
At least some people still care
Germans, recently privy to news that Europe’s biggest telecommunications firm was illegally wiretapping phone calls, are recalling what life was...
Invasions of Privacy
Laura Rosen hits on something that’s been bugging me about the passport story too: Seriously, what am I missing? Isn’t there some bizarre sort...